Understanding Security Force Court Martial Procedures in Boder Security Force

SECURITY FORCE COURT MARTIAL

Introduction

The security force court is the martial court deal with the matter relating to the offences committed by the members of the armed forces and decide the offence and the extent of punishment awarded to the offender.

Mentioned under chapter VI, section 64 – section 81 and procedure under section 82-section 106 of the BSF Act 1968 and Rules.

It explains three types of the security forces courts

  1. General security forces courts
  2. Petty security forces courts
  3. Summary security forces courts

The presiding member of the general and the petty security forces court is the senior member

General security force court

They are convened by the central government or the director general or any officer empowered. It consists of 5 officers who have held the post of the deputy superintendent of police. The general security force officer should be attended by the law officer and if the law officer not available then the officer approved by the chief law officer .

After the commencement of the trial the security force court is reduced to minimum number of officers required .

Dissolution of the security force court

The security force court should be dissolved when it is impossible to continue with the trial on the verge of illness of the law officer or the accused and the officer can also dissolve if he/she finds it difficult/inexpedient to continue.
After the dissolution the accused can be tried again.

    Power

The security force courts officer can try any person subject to the act ie. Falling within the perview of the BSF Act , and can award any punishment.

Petty security force court

The petty security forces court is convened by the general security force court or by the officer on his behalf. He should be attended by the law officer if not than by the officer approved by the chief law officer.

    Power

The petty security force court can try any person falling under the purview of the act except the officer made punishable thereunder and the sentence of a death or imprisonment term exceeding two years.

Summary security force court

         Power

  1. The summary security forces court can try the cases of no grave respond for immediate action and cannot try the offences punishable under sections 14, 17 and 26.
  2. They can try any person under the command of the officer holding the court.
  3. They cannot pass a death sentence or imprisonment exceeding 1 year (officer holding the post of superintendent of police or a post declared by the central government).
  4. Cannot try any person who has been already convicted under sections 53 and 55 of the BSF Act.
  5. If the person accused is not an officer and has been served continuously in an exemplary manner for not less than 3 years, no trial shall be conducted.
  6. If any officer or the member has ceased to be the subject to the act ie have stopped falling under the purview of the act be kept in the force custody and shall be tried as if he comes under the verge of the act.
  7. A person sentenced to imprisonment will be tried according to this act till the sentence although dismissed from the force.
  8. Being the fact that the jurisdiction is under the summary force court it will be in the discretion if the director general or the inspector general or the deputy inspector general within whom the accused serving, they will decide in which court the proceeding shall be instituted.
  9. When the criminal court is of the opinion that the proceeding should go under it, it will decide under section 80 either to deliver the offender to the nearest magistrate to proceed or to postpone proceeding.

ALSO READ Starting a New Business: The Importance of Legal Considerations and Fastrack Legal Solutions 2023

Procedure

  1. Before proceeding with the case, the name of the proceeding officer should be read over to accused if the accused objected, it should be heard and recorded, the remaining office will decide the matter if the objection allowed by one and half or more of the votes of officers.
  2. Oath and affirmation to every member of summary security force court and law officer before trial began, every person before giving evidence should be examined.

Every decision of security force court to be passed by absolute majority of votes or equality of votes.

  • Death sentence by the general security force court by at least two third member of court majority.
  • Indian Evidence Acts 1872 shall apply to all proceeding judicial notice of any matters can be taken.
  • The officers approved as convening offices, the presiding officer under section 83 shall attend at a time and place to the summon y=to give evidence or to produce document. For other witnesses the jurisdiction magistrate should send a summon, also the summon should specify the required submission of any document or the other thing.
  • If the custody under the district magistrate, thief presiding magistrate, high court, or the court of session may require the portal or telegraph authorities to deliver such document to such person as such magistrate.
  • When the witnesses reside in the tribal areas as outside India, the commission may be issued according to the chapter XI of CrPC.

Fastrack Legal Solutions +91 7697671219

The Evolution of Gender Justice in India

Gender rights are the claims and freedoms recognized by normative legal codes, social inclusion, and cultural practices on people as per their gender. These rights are critical for making possible equality, dignity, and non-discrimination while creating a balanced society. This is particularly true in India, where gender roles have been traditionally defined by societal norms. It has worked against stereotypes and has created a more inclusive framework through fighting gender rights.

The Constitution of India, through provisions like equality before the law (Article 14) and prohibition of discrimination on the grounds of sex (Article 15), has a robust basis for gender justice. However, often the reality is that the ground norms and internalized meanings of masculinity and femininity deeply root in patriarchal culture and this hinders the realization of equality in its true sense.

While women have historically faced structural discrimination and continue to fight for safety, representation, and equal opportunities, issues faced by men, such as the stigma around mental health and vulnerability to false accusations, remain underexplored. Similarly, the rights of transgender and non-binary individuals, despite legislative advancements like the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, are far from adequately safeguarded, with societal stigma and lack of infrastructure posing significant barriers.

Therefore, gender rights cannot be merely an ethical obligation, but a compulsion to realize in constructing a just society. Gender justice cannot be achieved by focusing solely on the challenges of one group while neglecting others. This article advocates for a holistic approach, emphasizing that every gender’s unique struggles and contributions must be acknowledged to create an ecosystem of equality and mutual respect. Only through such inclusivity can India progress towards true gender equity.

Historical Perspective on Gender Rights & Equality in India

Traditionally, Indian society has placed itself within rigid gender hierarchies according to religious and cultural norms. Texts, such as Manusmriti, have furthered such patriarchal structures by mandating that women have subordinate roles. In a similar way, non-binary and transgender identities were revered in India pre-colonialism because of their association with spiritual roles in both Hinduism and Islam. Later, through the ages of colonial rule, they were systematically marginalized.

The colonial period marked the beginning of legislative reforms addressing gender inequality. Initiatives like the abolition of Sati through the Bengal Sati Regulation (1829), the Hindu Widows’ Remarriage Act (1856), and the Child Marriage Restraint Act (1929) reflected early efforts to address gender injustices. These reforms, while groundbreaking, often faced resistance due to their challenge to entrenched socio-cultural practices.

With independence, gender equality became constitutional obligations. Fundamental rights were inserted in the Constitution of India for guaranteeing equality (Article 14), while prohibiting discrimination on all grounds such as sex (Article 15). Besides that, the Directive Principles of State Policy stated the obligation of the State to ensure equal remuneration, education, and prevention of exploitation.

The evolution of gender rights was further shaped by feminist movements in the 20th century, advocating for reforms like equal inheritance under the Hindu Succession Act (1956) and criminalizing dowry practices through the Dowry Prohibition Act (1961). Besides, the struggle of the LGBTQIA+ community accelerated with the sunset of two landmark judgments: NALSA v. Union of India (2014) and Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India (2018), granting the status of persons to transgender individuals and decriminalizing homosexuality, respectively.

Constitutional Provisions for Gender Rights & Equality

The Indian Constitution provides a strong foundation for gender equality through its fundamental rights and Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP).

Fundamental Rights

  • Article 14: Guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws, emphasizing non-discrimination across all genders.
  • Article 15: Prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth. Importantly, it allows the State to make special provisions for women and children to advance gender equity.
  • Article 16: Ensures equality of opportunity in public employment and prohibits discrimination on grounds of sex.
  • Article 21: Broadly interpreted to include the right to live with dignity, encompassing protection from gender-based violence and exploitation.

Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP)

  • Article 39: Directs the State to ensure that men and women equally have the right to an adequate means of livelihood and that equal pay is provided for equal work.
  • Article 42: Mandates the State to ensure just and humane working conditions and maternity relief.
  • Article 51A(e): Imposes a fundamental duty on citizens to renounce practices derogatory to the dignity of women.

Key Statutes and Provisions

For Women

  1. Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA): This act provides civil remedies for women facing domestic violence, addressing physical, emotional, sexual, and economic abuse. It offers immediate relief in the form of protection orders, residence orders, and monetary compensation.
  2. Maternity Benefit Act, 1961: Amended in 2017, this act enhances maternity leave to 26 weeks, provides crèche facilities, and ensures no discrimination against pregnant employees.
  3. Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act, 2013 (POSH Act): The act provides a framework for addressing sexual harassment in workplaces, mandating Internal Complaints Committees (ICCs) and emphasizing accountability.
  4. Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961: Criminalizes the practice of giving and receiving dowry, addressing a prevalent cause of harassment and violence against women.
  5. The Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971: This Act provides women with the right to access safe and legal abortions under specified conditions. In 2021, the Act was amended to extend the permissible gestation period for abortion to 24 weeks in special circumstances, including cases of rape, incest, or fetal abnormalities.
    Also Read Are Dating Apps Like Tinder Legal and Safe in India? Everything You Need to Know

Gender- Neutral Statutes & Provisions

  1. Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act): The POCSO Act is one of India’s most comprehensive gender-neutral laws. It addresses sexual offences against children under the age of 18, irrespective of their gender. The Act ensures that both male and female children, as well as those identifying as non-binary, are equally protected against abuse. It prescribes stringent punishments for perpetrators and provides for child-friendly mechanisms for reporting and investigation.
  2. Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015: The Juvenile Justice Act is gender-neutral in its approach to children in conflict with the law and those in need of care and protection. It does not differentiate based on gender and focuses on rehabilitation and reintegration, ensuring that all children are treated with dignity and equity.

Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019

This landmark legislation ensures the rights of transgender individuals by prohibiting discrimination in employment, education, and healthcare. It mandates the establishment of welfare boards and provides for identity recognition through certificates issued by authorities. However, the act has faced criticism for requiring individuals to seek validation of their gender identity from the State, which undermines self-determination.

The Overlooked Reality: Men’s Rights in the Gender Equality Discourse

For centuries, gender equality has been a pillar in many progressive societies, striving towards the elimination of all established barriers and discriminatory actions that have historically robbed women of their rights. But the larger discourse has overlooked man’s vulnerabilities and rights that create an imbalance in the understanding and implementation of gender justice. Such omission results from deep-rooted stereotypes, societal expectations, as well as a narrow definition of gender equality that focuses predominantly on women’s rights. While addressing disadvantages women have historically experienced, it is also essential investigating men’s disadvantages for an equitable society.

Men’s rights are often overshadowed by the larger movement for women’s empowerment. This neglect can be attributed to several factors:

  1. Historical Context: The gender equality movement emerged as a response to centuries of systemic oppression and inequality faced by women. In this context, men were often viewed as the dominant or privileged group, leading to the assumption that they do not face significant challenges or discrimination.
  2. Societal Perceptions of Masculinity: Traditional notions of masculinity portray men as strong, self-reliant, and invulnerable. This perception discourages men from expressing vulnerabilities or seeking support, further reinforcing the belief that men do not require rights-focused advocacy.
  3. Focus on Statistical Disparities: The focus on data highlighting women’s disadvantages in areas like education, employment, and safety often overshadows issues faced by men, such as mental health struggles, higher suicide rates, and workplace fatalities.

Key Areas Where Men’s Rights Are Overlooked

1. Mental Health and Emotional Well-being

Men face significant challenges in accessing mental health support due to societal stigmas around vulnerability. Cultural expectations often discourage men from expressing emotions or seeking help, leading to alarming statistics:

  • As per NCRB data, on an average, over the past eight years (2015 to 2022), nearly 1,01,188 men have died by suicide each year, compared to 43,314 women. The rate of suicide for men is 14.2 per 100,000 male population, while for women, it is 6.6 per 100,000 female population.

2. Domestic Violence Against Men

While the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) provides robust protections for women, no equivalent legal framework exists to address domestic violence faced by men. Reports and studies suggest that men can also be victims of physical, emotional, and financial abuse in intimate relationships. However, societal stereotypes often trivialize their experiences, which leads to underreporting and a lack of support structures.

3. False Allegations of Harassment or Rape

False accusations of harassment, dowry demands, or rape, though statistically rare, can have devastating consequences for men. Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), designed to protect women from cruelty by their husbands or in-laws, is often criticized for being misused. Men falsely accused of sexual offences face reputational damage, emotional trauma, and financial burdens, with limited recourse to seek justice or repair their lives.

4. Custody Rights in Divorce

In most divorce cases, the custody of children is awarded to mothers under the assumption that women are inherently better caregivers. While this may hold true in some situations, it often disregards the role of fathers in a child’s upbringing.

Laws such as the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 and judicial precedents typically favor mothers, leaving fathers with limited access to their children. This bias ignores the emotional and psychological impact of losing custody on fathers and children alike.

5. Workplace Harassment and Discrimination

The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act, 2013 (POSH Act) is an important tool for protecting women against workplace harassment. However, it is limited in scope, excluding men and LGBTQIA+ individuals from its protections. Men who experience workplace harassment often face ridicule or disbelief when they come forward, leaving them without adequate support or legal remedies.

Atul Subhash Suicide: A Tragic Reflection on the Lack of Visibility of Men’s Rights

In a deeply tragic incident that has reignited discussions about men’s rights in India, Atul Subhash, a 45-year-old man from Pune, took his own life after being ordered by the court to pay ₹5 crore as alimony in an old divorce case. Subhash left behind a suicide note highlighting the overwhelming financial burden and emotional distress that led him to take this drastic step. His case sheds light on the pressing need to reexamine the often-overlooked challenges faced by men in the context of marital disputes and gender justice.

Subhash had been embroiled in a long-standing divorce case with his former spouse. The Supreme Court ordered to pay a whopping ₹5 crore as alimony, which was the tipping point for him. His suicide note disclosed an unbearable pressure that was not only on monetary grounds but also emotional. This incident isn’t an isolated one; it mirrors the plight of many men who face severe mental health challenges due to societal expectations, legal biases, and limited avenues for support.

One of the critical issues highlighted by Atul’s case is the lack of legal and institutional safeguards for men. While significant progress has been made in addressing gender-based violence against women and LGBTQIA+ individuals, the legal framework often neglects situations where men are victims. For instance, laws addressing domestic violence and sexual harassment largely exclude men from their purview, perpetuating the notion that men cannot be victims. False accusations can have a catastrophic impact on a man’s personal and professional life, as societal biases often presume guilt without thorough investigation.

On the other hand, the aspect of men’s mental health is a serious issue. Far lesser men seek help for mental issues in comparison to women. Studies suggest that men have a higher rate of suicide. This is due to societal expectations and a lack of support systems. Despite this, mental health campaigns overlook the hurdles men face. As a result, men are left with no avenues for their remedial action.

Do Read Security Forces Court Martial

Article by Manan Mishra NLU Ranchi Intern at Fastrack Legal Solutions +917697671219

References

  1. Legal protections for husbands: What are men’s rights in marriage
  2. IJCRT2408302.pdf
  3. Will someone believe if a man reports an incident?
  4. Men’s Rights In India — Legal Desire Media and Insights
  5. Domestic Violence Against Men in India: A Constitutional Analysis
  6. Important Supreme Court And High Court Cases on Rights of Men And Judicial Intervention
  7. Key Legal Rights Every Woman in India Should Be Aware Of
  8. Domestic Violence Against Indian Men: 9 Facts & Stats
  9. Fight for Men’s Rights in India: Embracing Equality and Fairness
  10. Domestic Violence Against Men and Women in India: Why Blame Only Us If You Can Do It Too?
  11. The reasons for male suicides in India: What the numbers tell us
  12. Atul Subhash suicide: After asking man to pay Rs 5 crore in an old divorce case, SC lists 8 factors to decide alimony — The Economic Times

Indian Armed Forces, Stepsons, and Daughters of India

The Indian Army wanted 75 per cent of personnel recruited under the new scheme – Agnipath – to be retained, former army chief Gen MM Naravane writes in his upcoming memoir – ‘Four Stars of Destiny’.

https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/policy/story/army-wanted-75-retention-in-agnipath-scheme-writes-gen-mm-naravane-in-memoir-410098-2023-12-19

The Indian Constitution’s Article 19(1)(a) protects the right to free speech. This clause states that every citizen has the right to freedom of speech and expression. The judiciary has emphasized how crucial free expression is to a democracy. As the cornerstone of a democratic government, it is essential to the democratic process’s successful operation. The right to free speech and expression is ranked first in the hierarchy of rights and is regarded as a requirement for all other rights. It is commonly called a fundamental human right and a natural right. Subramanian Swamy VS Union of India, Ministry of Law

But when the ruling regimes are afraid of their own faults, this prerogative is rendered meaningless. The account of the cruel methods of governing is evident in the memoir of the former Chief of Army Staff, General MM Naravanve, which is currently awaiting government approval for publication.

They respond immediately to national requirements, whether they are caused by man-made or natural disasters. However, when it comes time for them to be rewarded, they face factors such as pay reductions, reduced pension benefits, and disability benefits.

The major risks are eliminated by the men and women dressed in olive greens and beyond, but as they say in politics, the political masters are busy reducing disability payments and preparing to place financial burdens on the countries. Surprisingly, political elites believe they understand how to manage the armed forces, yet they utterly neglect to acknowledge the kinds of challenges the forces must overcome. Disability pensions are due to burecrats lounging in air-conditioned chambers, while the hard-fought benefits must come from the rough terrain soldiers.

The Indian Express reported that defence pensions have increased over the past five years, from Rs 1.08 lakh crore in 2018-19 to Rs 1.38 lakh crore in 2023-24. The amount allocated for disability pensions also witnessed significant growth over the past two decades, reaching around Rs 4,000 crore in 2022-23, it said, citing government sources.

The Indian express

“I wonder whether those of our political masters who have been put in charge of the defence of the country can distinguish a mortar from a motor; a gun from a howitzer; a guerrilla from a gorilla, although a great many resemble the latter.”

Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw

There is a big difference between theatrics and actual welfare; celebrations may have taken place with the soilders by the Prime Minister of our nation, but the policies haven’t been inclined towards the welfare of the troops for sure.

With the Agniveer scheme coming in, the dynamics of the forces have changed. With under-trained individuals taking the reins of the horse called national security, the difference is clear. With a significant number of these Agniveers dropping out during training and others after joining the army, navy, and air force, it calls for a reevaluation.

Agnipath Scheme Was ‘Bolt Out of the Blue’ for Navy and Air Force: Former Army Chief Naravane

The idea of a nation is based on the welfare of its troops and farmers. , the welfare of farmers was clear with the robust year-long protest, and the soilders cant protest as they are not legally allowed to form unions. The divide between the serving and the veterans is created by pushing policies that state that they are only applicable to serving soldiers and there is no policy change for the veterans.

The nation certainly wants to know: where does the “fauji” go?

In his book, which will hit the stand next month, Naravane says the first year’s starting salary for the new inductees was kept at just Rs 20,000 per month (all-inclusive) and that was “not acceptable”. 

“This was just not acceptable,” the former army chief writes, as per news agency PTI. “Here, we were talking about a trained soldier who was expected to lay down his life for the country. Surely a soldier could not be compared with a daily wage laborer.”

“When I had first sounded out the PM about the Tour of Duty scheme, it was more on the lines of a short-service option at the soldier level, similar to the Short Service Commission scheme for officers that was already in vogue. Just as a limited number of SSC officers are taken each year, likewise a limited number of jawans would be similarly enrolled and released after the completion of their ‘tour’ with the option of re-enlisting for another tour, if found to be fit,” he writes.

The General further writes that nothing much happened in the next couple of months due to Covid and the clashes in Galwan in Ladakh. However, he writes, the prime minister’s office was considering this proposal, but with a much wider scope and applicability. “In the PMO formulation, not only should the complete intake of the year be short-service based, but it would also apply to all three services.”

Naravane writes having become a tri-service matter, it now fell on the CDS Gen Bipin Rawat to take the proposal forward, albeit with the army remaining the lead service. He says it took him some time to explain to the other chiefs that his proposal had only been army-centric. “And it took them some time to reconcile with the fact that they were very much part of the new proposal, dubbed the ‘Agnipath’ scheme by the PMO, with the soldiers, sailors and airmen recruited under this scheme to be known as ‘Agniveers’,” he notes.

Business Today

The Agniveer scheme was just the beginning; the new disability regime, which was rolled out on September 21, 2023 , was another major jolt , as it aimed at eliminating all already-set legal precedents with respect to disability pension, The late Manhonar Parikar ji then defense minister, passed a ministerial order that the defence ministry would not appeal any order passed by the armed forces tribunal with respect to disability pensions.

It is not just a setback to the forces but also to the members, who have been backstabbed by some within the system. Would the step-child treatment stop any day soon ?

The All India Ex-Servicemen Welfare Association demanded a repeal of the new rules in a letter to the MoD last week. Bhim Sen Sehgal, chairperson of the ex-servicemen association, said in a statement, “The definition of invalidation has also been changed in a regressive manner, and it has been reiterated that there would be a requirement of ten years of service to earn an invalid pension. This requirement was already abrogated for civilian employees in January 2019.“

The service connection of disabilities has also been altered, belying medical science and common sense. For example, the existing rules and also the CCS (EOP) rules for civilians, provide that all heart diseases are linked with stress and strain of service without any preconditions attached. However, the new rules of the MoD state that heart diseases shall only be considered as linked with service in case the same occurs in high altitude areas,” the statement said, pointing out that the stress and strain of military service could happen irrespective of the area where soldiers are posted.

Though the legal side of this argument is bright but the men in unfirom would have to fight a long battle in courts too to get the disability entitled to them.

I will end this article by what Sam Mahekshaw once said

A ‘yes man’ is a dangerous man. He is a menace. He will go very far. He can become a minister, a secretary or a Field Marshal but he can never become a leader or be respected.

Adv Govind Bali 

Managing Partner Fatsrack Legal Solutions

Union Budget 2023: Rs 5.94 Lakh Crore Allocated To Defence Ministry, 13% increase as compared to previous year

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Wednesday presented the Union Budget 2023 in Parliament. This year, defence allocations grew by 12.9 percent as compared to the previous financial year. The budgetary allocation for defence for FY 2023–24 is Rs 5.93 lakh crore. Meanwhile, last year, it was Rs 5.25 lakh crore.

Union Budget 2023: Rs 5.94 Lakh Crore Allocated To Defence Ministry, 13% increase as compared to previous year

Flesh trade

The day I realized I was born in a traders
Country
Here life had no value ,vote banks and Swiss banks ruled all the things that happened
They divided us into three they said they were making us free
It was just flesh trade for some billion of pennys and gallons of blood spread all around
With each passing day they trade lives for votes
Every passing day someone dies
Someone’s son,father,brother
Family cries these politicians rejoice
For another vote bank blood shed they get
I plead with tearfull eyes realize the value of life
Those who died today for your tomorrow belonged to a family
Those children still cry and plead for love
Oh flesh traders realize the worth of life
-Govind Bali

Competition Commission of India V the Big Giants  Oyo Makemy Trip and GoIbibo

Competition Commission of India V the Big Giants  

The Competition Commission of India (CCI) slapped penalties totalling more than ₹392 crore on online travel firms MakeMyTrip, Goibibo and hospitality services provider OYO for unfair business practices. (“MakeMyTrip, Goibibo, Oyo Face CCI Penalties Totalling Rs. 392 Crore”) Unfair business practices include misrepresentation, false advertising, or representation of a good or service, tied selling, false free prize or gift offers, deceptive pricing, and noncompliance with manufacturing standards. What is of essence here is that these companies have been in the tally of top companies when it comes to the online hotel booking regime. What was alleged is that MMT-Go imposed a price parity in their agreements with hotel partners. Under such pacts, the hotel partners are not allowed to sell their rooms on any other platform or on its own online portal at a price below the price at which it is being offered on the two entities’ platforms. Which is again leads to the issue abuse of dominant position which has been well defined in the Competition act of India. 

Besides the penalties, CCI has directed MMT-Go to modify its agreements with hotels and hotel chains. 

 Before we go any further, we need to understand what the objectives of competition commission of India are  

The objectives of the Act are sought to be achieved through the Competition Commission of India, which has been established by the Central Government with effect from 14th October 2003. CCI consists of a chairperson and 6 Members appointed by the Central Government. 
It is the duty of the Commission to eliminate practices having adverse effect on competition, promote and sustain competition, protect the interests of consumers and ensure freedom of trade in the markets of India. 
The Commission is also required to give opinion on competition issues on a reference received from a statutory authority established under any law and to undertake competition advocacy, create public awareness and impart training on competition issues. 

But why was this fine imposed? 

The issue dates to 2019 when FHRAI (Federation of Hotel & Restaurant Associations of India), along with Treebo and FabHotels took MMT-Go (the merged entity of MakeMyTrip-Go Ibibo) and OYO to the CCI. The acquisition levied on MakeMyTrip was of colluding with OYO and abusing their dominance as an undeclared cartel and controlling prices in the market are large. 
Primary allegations against MMT  
There were 3 main concerns 

1: MMT-Go enforced price parity in its agreement with hotel partners. So, if the likes of Treebo and FabHotels intended to list one of their properties at a lower price with a different aggregator or on their own website, they were not allowed to do so. 

2: MMT-Go was indulging in “predatory pricing” i.e., they were offering extremely deep discounts on room rates in a bid to corner the online travel agent (OTA) market. 

3: MMT-Go also extended preferential treatment to OYO and restricted FabHotels and Treebo from accessing India’s biggest OTA platform. 

Now why were these issues of Importance being another question 

  1. With an enforced price parity there was limitation to the hotels to access or give their services to other websites which was hampering their right to conduct business freely which is not only a commercial default but also leads to constitutional breach. 
  1. With offering of predatory pricing MMT was killing the essence of fair trade and pricing such pricing was delimiting other organisations from business as they were not able to sustain the brunt from these predatory prices. 
  1. Preferential treatment also leads to a failed free trade regime where in only a selected few get the opportunity to participate in a market. 

Indeed, here’s MMT’s perspective. They accepted the complete market ought to incorporate both on the web and disconnected channels. They additionally accepted it ought to incorporate direct lodging sites close by Search, Find, and Book (SCB) stages like Google. In entirety, they believed that the CCI should consider all that while choosing the important market here. 

Be that as it may, CCI didn’t exactly concur with this appraisal. 

It said these contentions were ‘confused and self-serving, regardless of the level of refinement with which they have been introduced’. And afterward utilized MMT-Go’s own examination report from two or a long time back to come to its meaningful conclusion. 

Individuals who book lodgings online are particularly not quite the same as the people who converse with a rikshaw driver to track down an inn. These business sectors are fundamentally unrelated, and the two modes don’t actually take care of similar sort of clients. 

Additionally, most lodgings recorded on OTAs don’t have their own sites. They don’t have a dependable client base and they’re looking for perceivability when they go on these stages. Truth be told, MMT-Go’s own report expresses those unbranded lodgings shaped 72% of its stock in 2018. So immediate site appointments were probably not going to shape a significant piece of the important market. 

Lastly, the Inquiry, Find, and Book contention with Google. 

 CCI utilized screen captures from a report distributed by MMT-Go to demonstrate that the tech monster wasn’t a danger. While Google permitted examinations on its pursuit site, clients couldn’t actually book a room on the web index. All things considered; it normally diverted you to the OTA itself. Also, OTAs could run promotions to highlight on top of the list items. It was a promoting stage and not really a circulation stage. Nonetheless, MMT made the greater part of its cash when someone booked a room through the stage. So here and there, they dispersed the stock. Also, their own report expressed that Google guided 42% of all traffic to its site. 

So, toward the finish, all things considered, the CCI noticed that the applicable market comprises just of ‘online delegates for booking lodgings in India’. 

However, CCI accepts these agreements are innately hostile to serious. 

 For example, expect there is another minimal expense OTA stage that means to disturb the market. It vows to charge a lower commission contrasted with the officeholders. And afterward arranges a superior cost with the lodging. Nevertheless, to offer this deal cost to clients, it cannot. Since then, the inn will undoubtedly offer MakeMyTrip a similar room at the very same cost since they have an agreement that specifies this plan. 

 What is more, we should assume both MMT-Go and the new contestant presently get to list this stock at this proper cost. From here on in, the two stages can practice watchfulness on whether they need to expand further limits on this “set value.” And this is where MMT’s abundant resources can truly cause the harm. They can limit the cost extensively since they rule the market. 

 For example, according to the CCI report: 

 “The information on room evenings on which limits are given demonstrates that biggest number of room evenings on which over 30% markdown is given are reserved through MMT-Go. Expedia has presented that normal markdown given by Expedia from 2013-2019 was on a normal underneath 5%.” 

 Also, CCI accepted that MMT did this not to draw in new clients but to drive out contest. 

 However, is this ruthless? 

Indeed, to decide this, CCI would have needed to show that MMT-Go was limiting the rooms underneath cost. Furthermore, since they were not completely content with the computations, they gave MMT a pass on the issue. 

 Lastly, the worry with OYO. 

 Both MMT and OYO surrendered that they had select arrangements set up to delist other franchisee inns. Yet, they contended that this was a simply prudent endeavour. For example, MMT took a gander at development measurements from Treebo, FabHotels, and OYO during 2016-2018. During this time, OYO was nott recorded on MMT, however the others were. And keeping in mind that OYO figured out how to develop dramatically, the others were all the while battling to make a scratch. So MMT perceived the need to have OYO on its foundation and afterward took the cognizant choice to delist Treebo and FabHotels since OYO demanded it. 

 Yet, did that take the others of down? 

Indeed, OYO brings up that it no affected FabHotels’ incomes. Furthermore, Treebo’s income hopped from ₹4.6 crores at the hour of delisting (April 2018) to ₹6.1 crores by December 2019. So where could the effect have been? 

Judicial Independence a Myth ?

Judicial Independence a Myth ?

Adv Govind Bali

“The bedrock of our democracy is the rule of law and that means we have to have an independent judiciary, judges who can make decisions independent of the political winds that are blowing.”

The judicial independence was secured by the Act of Settlement 1701. Though, in India, there is no express provision in the Constitution, but the independence of Judiciary and rule of law are the basic features of the Constitution and cannot be abrogated even by constitutional amendments as observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in S.P. Gupta v Union of India, AIR 1962 SC 149.

In the past few months, the political influence on judiciary has been rampant, with senior advocates who have been in the court for decades have pointed out the disparity

With Sr. Adv Kapil Sibal point out a significant issue which has been known to all but talked by none

“Agar aap history of the court pichle kuch saal ki dekhoge, a lot of sensitive cases in which the government is involved will go only to a particular judge … ab ye random toh ho nahi sakta…toh wo kyu assign hota hain? As quoted by Live law

Are we depleting the Independence of Judiciary? With the ex chief justice of India being given a seat at Rajya Sabha, and judgements been passed to suspend acquittals is a new development ‘Never Heard of Judges Suspending Acquittal In A Special Saturday Hearing’: Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal On Supreme Court Order In Prof. GN Saibaba Case.

Even the collegium system have been at the beating head by political maestros who debate that the collegium is a time taking process and reduces the time that is devoted to the actual judicial work, Kiren Rijiju has been advocating that a new process should be in place to replace the collegium system , would this new system be another step towards the depleting judicial independence ? The answer to this question is still in the womb and the foetus is still prenatal.

The independence of Judiciary and the fundamental right to free speech and expression are of an excellent value and both are required to be balanced. What is more astonishing is the issue which leads to a gaged judicial system.

The independence of the judiciary is a very precious and fundamental concept, which needs to be preserved. What could be a go to remedy to preserve judicial independence is a country which runs on political emotions having a topping of religious flavours.

But is the clamour real or manufactured?

There are various views that can be taken to this question and one of the views could be in the words of Law Minister Kiren Rijiju

“Judges work a lot. They should not be attacked with bad words. It is not the case, that cases are not being settled but understand that double the number of cases are being filed every day. From minor to major issues, all matters are reaching Courts“

There Are Whispers That Collegium Will Recommend Only Names Acceptable To Centre : Senior Adv CS Vaidyanathan

While the other view could be the one taken by  Former judge Justice A.P. Shah, while giving his preliminary comments on the Chhattisgarh encounters case stated that instead of appreciating the courage of the tribals and ordering an independent inquiry, the Supreme Court penalised the tribals on an inquiry made by police, which was the accused in the case. He expressed his shock over the approach adopted by the Supreme Court in this case. He said that the occurrence of the massacre was not in dispute and even if the victim’s allegations that it was the police and security forces who assaulted them was not to be believed on its face value, still the criminal jurisprudence mandates for a fair and independent investigation. He further emphasized that the Supreme Court completely overlooked the struggle through which the unfortunate adivasi victims managed to reach this court and instead of forming an SIT for investigation, it went on to impose an exemplary cost of 5 lakhs on Petitioner No. 1. He questioned what sort of criminal justice this was? Expressing disappointment, Justice Shah said that he himself had been a judge and seen many such proceedings but the tendency of denying independent investigation and imposing fine upon the petitioners was not a healthy sign.

“Instead of appreciating the courage of the tribals& ordering an in-depth inquiry, the SC penalised them on inquiry by police which was accused”

At the Gujarat High Court, while upholding the conviction of 19 persons for murder of 23 people including women and children during the 2002 Gujarat riot (Oad massacre case), Justice Kureshi made certain moving observations about “communal frenzy” and how it turns normal human beings into “murderous monsters”.

“These phenomena which we often describe as communal frenzy turn perfectly normal human beings momentarily into murderous monsters leaving nothing but trail of death and destruction for the victims and his own family alike”, Justice Kureshi stated in his judgment. This judgement could a reason for his non elevation to the supreme court

Former CJI Ranjan Gogoi reveals in his autobiography that the Collegium proposal as regards Justice Kureshi’s elevation had to be altered after the objection raised by the Union Government.

“The objection was based on a negative perception flowing from certain judicial orders passed by Justice Kureshi”, Gogoi says without giving out further details. He further says that “to avoid a confrontation between the two constitutional bodies”, Justice Kureshi’s recommendation was modified. This revelation hits out the clear role of executive interference in the Judicial functioning.

Interestingly, in his farewell speech, Justice Kureshi said that he considered this “negative perception” of Centre as a “certificate of independence”.

“As a judge of the Constitutional Court, whose most primary duty is to protect the fundamental and human rights of the citizens, I consider it a certificate of independence”, he said. He also said, “I leave with my pride intact that I made no decision based on its consequences for me”.

The debate is endless and the issue is not the one which can be ignored we need to look into the independence of judiciary to safe guard the constitution

Everything You Need to Know About Surrogacy Law in India

Everything You Need to Know About Surrogacy Law in India

If you want to start a family through surrogacy in India but aren’t sure how this process works, you’ve come to the right place! Find out everything you need to know about surrogacy law in India here, including which states allow it and who can be your surrogate. For more tips on how to pursue your dreams of having a family through surrogacy, check out our full guide here!

5 things you should know before becoming a surrogate parent
While many people consider becoming a surrogate parent for infertile couples, only about 1% of women who apply are accepted. Here’s what you need to know before making your choice.

  1. It can be a great opportunity if you have been unable to conceive on your own: Women have all sorts of reasons why they want to become surrogates, but one of the most common is that they have been unable to get pregnant themselves. Becoming a surrogate gives them an opportunity not just to help someone else become pregnant but also realize their own dreams of motherhood—no matter how big or small those dreams might be.
  2. There are a lot of legal and medical issues involved: If you’re thinking about becoming a surrogate, you need to know that there are many legal and medical issues involved—and they vary from state to state. That’s why it’s important for potential surrogates to find a lawyer who is experienced with surrogacy law, as well as an OB/GYN or fertility specialist who can explain all of your options and help you make an informed decision.
  3. It’s not always easy being pregnant: One reason some women decide not to become surrogates is because they don’t realize how challenging pregnancy can be. Even if you have been able to get pregnant on your own, pregnancy isn’t always easy; carrying another child can be physically demanding and emotionally draining.
  4. It’s not just about giving someone else a baby: When you become a surrogate, you’re making an incredible gift of yourself—both physically and emotionally. It’s important for all parties involved to understand that surrogacy is about so much more than just giving someone else a baby; it’s also about helping two people fulfill their dream of becoming parents and creating their own family unit.
  5. It’s not always a happy ending: While most surrogacy arrangements end happily, there are times when things don’t work out as planned. It’s important for all parties involved to understand that surrogacy is about more than just giving someone else a baby; it’s also about helping two people fulfill their dream of becoming parents and creating their own family unit—and that doesn’t always happen.

6 rights and responsibilities of parents who use surrogates
Although surrogacy laws vary widely from state to state, and country to country, there are some rights that parents who use a surrogate should be aware of. In addition, prospective parents should know about any special responsibilities they’ll have as surrogacy parents. Note: The following information is intended as general guidance for what’s likely included in most state’s surrogacy laws. If you want specific legal advice about your situation, contact an attorney licensed in your state.
1) Legal parentage — Parentage means being recognized as a parent under law and having parental rights and responsibilities. In states where surrogacy contracts are legally enforceable, a court will determine whether or not someone is a child’s legal parent after birth. Most courts will base their decision on whether or not someone meets all of these conditions: • They’re married to or in a domestic partnership with one of the child’s biological parents • They plan to raise the child with their spouse or partner • They intend to make their home where their child lives
2) Allocation of parental responsibility — Parents can agree on how decisions will be made regarding their children when they’re together and when they’re apart. This includes decisions like education, religion, health care and more.
3) Right to access medical history — Before entering into a surrogacy agreement, it’s important to understand how much access you’ll have to medical records related to your child.
4) Child support — Some courts may order genetic parents who aren’t raising their own children financially responsible for them if it’s determined that they could afford it (even if they don’t).
5) Visitation/parenting time with the surrogate mother — This can be especially important if she decides she wants her own relationship with her child.
6) Who gets custody if something happens? Since there are no guarantees in life, it’s smart to think through what would happen if something were to happen before or during pregnancy. For example, if something happened while pregnant, who would get custody of your embryo?

Conclusion
Having a child is one of life’s most profound wishes. Unfortunately, many couples can’t do so for health reasons or because their partner is infertile. These people don’t lose hope, as there are other ways to bring children into their lives. Such a way of having children is surrogacy. This option lets people have children that share their genetics, but aren’t genetically related to them at all. However, there are legal issues involved with surrogacy. In order to understand these issues better and learn how they affect your situation, it’s important you consult an experienced attorney who has experience with surrogacy law in India. Your attorney will be able to answer any questions you may have and help you navigate through any legal challenges you may face during your journey towards parenthood. A good attorney will also ensure that your rights and interests are protected throughout the process and beyond.

Agnipath a miscalculated step

Aganipath Scheme a miscalculated step towards western approach

           There are countries which have a system of compulsory military service for a certain time period, after the completion of this compulsory service period the recruited individual have an option exist from the service, this is generally done to make people combat ready in countries where population is low and requirement of combat trained men is high, while some larger countries do the same to be battle ready. Why has this step been taken by India to retain only 25% men from those recruited under new scheme? The answer is simple Agnipath scheme has been formulated to ease the burden on the defence budget.  

           The speculations that have been brought up are real there will a sudden increase of burden on regular men in the army as the present retries which is about 1 lakh people a year will be replaced by only twenty five  thousand regular soldiers joining  the army every year , it is subsequent to note that the technical staff cannot be trained in a period of four years , and the police notion bias will always stay as no fixed criteria has been laid down as to on what parameters people would make to the selected few 25% of the soldiers.

Why don’t we rather come up with ideas which would help generate more defense revenue? with the prime minister saying the drones will play an important role in the defense sector, would the new drone operators not need adequate training? How would the military experience count when an induvial would mostly have one station to be posted at or at most two?

Why is it the armed forces who always have to face the wrath of the Babu’s and netas ? We should rather have a 4 years administrative service with no pension as sitting in AC room is always more convenient than the frostbiting cold of Siachen. Military has always come to rescue when the administration has failed to full fill its duty. Does the frontline warrior not deserve equal treatment, even if an individual becomes Member of Parliament for a day he gets life long pension, but four years in the army gives you nothing.

While there are some Netas who are saying they would employee agniveers as their security guards is this the respect that uniform deserves?

Why cant CSR  funds be pushed in as surplus to defense budget ? Why can not there be a pay cut in the security of ministers and that fund be used in the defense budget? Answer is simple the netas are concerned only for their own pocket.

Is Bilkis Bano a Lesser daughter of India?

Is Bilkis Bano a Lesser daughter of India?

The remission of convicts in the Bilkis Bano Case have been making headlines, as the remission has outraged many while some are celebrating. Is this the fist time when remission has been given in a rape case? Well there have been instances where remission has been given in heinous crimes and convicts have been released, In 2022 another such remission made headlines when The convict of Jessica Lal Murder case Manu Sharma was granted remission from his 24years and 4 months sentence, as he was released after 17 years of imprisonment.

Thinkers like G.W.F Hegel have often reasoned that the criminals are to be penalized for the offence they have committed, yet they have the right to be honoured as coherent beings when the establishments perpetrate the punishment on them.

The criminal jurisprudence across the globe has come a long way from using punishment for imparting fear is the public to understanding punishment as a species of secular penance, that aims to coax reprobates to repentance, serf-reform and resolve. India  has engaged several positive steps in this way  as can be seem in the  Indian Supreme Court’s recent unearthing of a relapsing punishment and reintroducing it in today’s time has taken us a step backwards in our thrive to achieve a modern, reformatory criminal justice system.

 In India, the sentence of life imprisonment in certain cases, when subject to remission, normally works out to a term of 14 years, however after the case of Union of India vs. V. Sriharan (2016), where a five judge bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India adjudicated the matter, a special category of punishment can be imposed by the concerned High Court and the Supreme Court providing for a specific term of incarceration without the possibility or opportunity of remission.

But one needs to understand in case of mass murders, multiple heinous offence, crimes against humanity the mentality of an accused is in such state of mind that the accused may have very few chances to rehabilitate, and they may become a threat to the society.

Remission is not a right It is true that no prisoner can seek remission as a matter of right. However, if a statute or statutory Rule or a Policy of the State Government provides for grant of remission in terms thereof a prisoner is entitled to be considered for grant of remission. The right of the prisoner is confined to the consideration his case for granting remission in accordance with law.

What also needs to be taken consideration is As observed earlier, in the case of State of Haryana Vs. Mohinder Singh & Ors , the decision to grant remission has to be reasonable and fair to all the concerned and that the grant of remission is statutory. The object of providing for judicial appraisal is to ensure that the Order or the Policy or the Rules of the State Government for grant of remissions are applied and implemented reasonably and fairly. When a Judicial Officer makes a judicial appraisal of the entitlement of the prisoner for grant of the State remission under the said Government Circular, the scope of judicial appraisal is to examine whether the case of the prisoner is covered by the Order contained in the said Government Resolution/Circular.

No reasonable classification has been made for the remission that was granted to convicts in the Bano Case, what is also need to be taken into consideration is that the remission has been done taking the old rules into consideration and new 2014 law is been ignored can an old law have prospective effect, is another question that needs answering